Fentner

Markets · Opinion

Your SaaS vendor is selling you code an agent can copy in a weekend

If agents can rewrite a vendor's product in a weekend, buyers should stop paying for code and pay for data, distribution and accountability. Most renewals still price the code.

Next time a renewal lands on your desk, ask the vendor which part of the invoice is code. Most of them will answer with a feature list, and I think that answer is now worth far less than the number beside it.

Martin Alderson argues that software margins were never about monopoly, network effects or corruption. They came from too few people being able to build the stuff, and agents are ending that scarcity. I agree with the diagnosis. He writes it as a problem for founders and finance teams, though, and I think the bigger consequence falls on the people signing the cheques.

Take his M&A example. An acquirer that once paid ten times revenue for a startup was in effect buying back two years and a team of 30 engineers. Once an in-house team with agents can do the same job in a few weeks, he reckons the technology adds next to nothing to the price, and only the customers and the distribution are left to pay for. Run the same arithmetic on a licence. Every buyer is making a build-or-buy decision at every renewal, and the build side of that decision has just got cheaper. This helps even if you never build anything, because a credible build option gives you leverage at the renewal.

Vendors used to have two answers to that threat. The first was that the product was too big to copy. Alderson points to the ArtCraft clones of everything from Excel to Photoshop, and to his claim that the Photoshop clone already has more features than GIMP, which has had 30 years of human effort. Plenty of people will say the clones are rough, and he concedes they are probably less stable. They do not have to be as good. They only have to sit on the table as a number during negotiation. The second answer was that leaving would hurt. He notes that agents can now export your data, transform it, and reverse engineer a web app to get it out when the vendor offers no export. If that holds up in practice, the exit penalty shrinks as well.

So what is left to pay for? I would pay for three things. The first is data the vendor holds that you cannot regenerate: the feeds, benchmarks and history that no agent can conjure from screenshots. The second is distribution, meaning access to the buyers, partners or marketplace that a clone does not come with. Alderson's Baumol point matters here. Building got 10x quicker while selling to B2B buyers did not, so whoever already has the customers keeps something valuable. The third is accountability: a named company that picks up the phone, fixes the fault and carries the loss.

The best objection is that running software costs more than writing it, and that I would be swapping a vendor for my own pager. The Replit agent that deleted SaaStr's production database in July 2025 is the example people reach for, and it is a fair one. I take it as support for my argument. If accountability is what you are really buying, it should be priced and written down as accountability. Read the liability clause before you read the price page. If the vendor's exposure is capped at what you pay them, you are buying code and getting no accountability, and code is the part that has lost its value.

Where I part company with Alderson is the idea that the value of everything already built has fallen by something like 90%. That is too tidy. The writedown will land on seat-priced mid-tier tools with thin data and no distribution of their own: the generic CRM, the form builder, the workflow app. Vendors that own a data asset or a channel will mostly hold their prices, and some will raise them, because the code around the data no longer costs them anything to produce.

Before your next renewal, give one engineer a weekend and an agent, and ask them to rebuild the core screens of your most expensive mid-tier tool. Walk into the meeting with the result and ask for the invoice split into data, distribution and accountability. A vendor that can fill in only one of those three lines should be quoting you a much lower price.

Prompted by The great software IP writedown, Martin Alderson.