Markets · Opinion
Never pay a seat fee and an outcome fee for the same AI agent
Zendesk's live price list charges per seat and per resolution at once. Buyers should demand outcome pricing that replaces the seat fee, with refunds when the agent fails.
Zendesk's live price list, as checked on 11 November, charges for seats. Every agent seat on every plan comes with a monthly allowance of 5 to 10 tickets the AI closes on its own, and anything beyond that costs $1.50 committed or $2.00 pay-as-you-go. That is a seat fee and an outcome fee on one invoice, for the same ticket. The seat-free plans that opened to early access on 10 November are a separate programme. The list above is what a rep quotes you today.
I expected vendors to be further along. The Tight and VSG survey of 126 vertical software founders and operators found 58% still tie AI to the seat, and 15% charge on outcomes. Those are vendors answering about their own pricing, and the sample is self-reported, so I would not stretch it to a market census. But it shows what the default is when a salesperson draws up your order form: the seat stays, and the new meter goes on top.
The incentive is easy to follow. In the same survey, 69% listed agents that replace headcount as part of their AI strategy. The report calls that intent, not deployed automation, and the authors say it is a separate finding from the seat figure. Still, run the logic. If an agent really does take over tickets, the customer needs fewer agent seats, and the vendor's seat revenue shrinks with them. A resolution meter is how the vendor recovers that money. Keeping the seat as well gives it a floor underneath. You pay once for the human you no longer need and again for the work the software now does.
Intercom already sells the alternative. Its help page of 23 September lists $0.99 per outcome for the Fin agent and nothing when the outcome does not happen. I cannot tell you that Zendesk's $1.50 and Intercom's $0.99 describe the same unit, because each vendor defines a resolution its own way, and that definition is where the fight will be. But a price with no charge on failure is the term to put in front of every vendor that quotes you a per-resolution rate.
The best objection is the vendors' own. The report says bundling AI into seats may simplify procurement and speed adoption, and 44% of respondents do exactly that. A flat seat price is easy to get through finance, while a meter is a budget line nobody can forecast. I take that seriously. But Zendesk already prices predictability: the committed rate is lower than pay-as-you-go. Buyers can have a forecastable bill by committing to a volume of resolutions with a cap, and that should cost them less than a seat on top. Procurement convenience does not justify paying for both.
Buyers also have more leverage than they think. In the survey, 28% of vendors say annual contract value has not improved, the largest single answer, and 55% say net revenue retention is unchanged. The report does not claim AI caused either figure. But it suggests that for many vendors the agent has not yet raised what customers pay, and a vendor with flat numbers will take a restructured deal more readily than one with a growing pipeline. I expect that to change once the first big price rises land.
So write the terms before the renewal call. Define a resolution as a ticket the customer does not reopen within a window you name. Bill nothing for a handoff to a human. Credit every failed attempt. And if the order form carries both a per-agent seat price and a bundled resolution allowance, as Zendesk's plans do, ask the rep to take the allowance's value off the seat price in writing. If the discount comes back as zero, you have found out which product the seat is really paying for.
Prompted by Zendesk tests outcome pricing as 58% stay on seats, hsdigital.substack.com.