Fentner

Money · Opinion

Take your agent call logs to the renewal meeting and demand 80% off

Vendors will not cut prices on their own, because their boards and sales plans depend on uplifts. Buyers with agent usage data should force the cut at renewal, and offer volume in return.

Jason Lemkin runs SaaStr with 3 humans and 20+ AI agents. One of his core vendors saw its bill rise 40% this year, almost all of it from AI usage. His agents were hitting that system about 35,000 times a day, and he cut those calls by about 90%. I expected a story about a vendor being taught a lesson. What I read was a customer doing the vendor's pricing review for it, with no meeting and no discount request, and the vendor presumably never noticed it had lost nine tenths of its usage.

Lemkin's advice is aimed at vendors: cut your price, perhaps by 80%. I accept his arithmetic. Take 80% off the unit price, get 20x the usage, and revenue from that customer goes up 4x. I do not believe many vendors will act on it unprompted. He lists the reasons himself: the board's net revenue retention model assumes price increases, sales comp is built on seats, and the plan assumes renewal uplifts. A CFO who proposes a 50% cut on one tier is proposing to give back revenue already booked. That CFO will find a reason to run the test next year.

So the cut has to come from the buyer, and the renewal is where to ask for it. Lemkin describes the vendor's side well: annual prepays, auto-renewals, built-in uplifts, shelfware everyone tolerates. All of it works because the human buyer stops paying attention. Your agents pay attention every day. They know cost per call and cost per task, and you can pull that data before the meeting. Walk in with calls per day, spend per call, and the number of calls you have throttled because the price made them not worth making. A seat price charges for a person to log in. Your agent never logs in, so the vendor is asking you to pay a human rate for a machine's access.

The vendors are also telling every customer they have refounded the product for AI, with agents and API-first rebuilds. Fine. Then ask what the rebuild did to their cost of delivery, and what you get for the 8% uplift on the renewal quote. Lemkin quotes his own question to vendors, "did you add 30% more value to your product?", and I would put it to the account executive in those words. If the answer is a roadmap slide, ask for the uplift to come off the quote.

The best objection comes from the vendor's finance team: inference costs money, and a flat cut ruins gross margin. Lemkin concedes that margins look worse at first. I think the answer is that margin is the vendor's problem to solve through volume, and the volume is what the buyer is offering. Databricks charged $1,000 per user on top of consumption. Its CRO Ron Gabrisko, as Lemkin tells it, heard from customers that the fee was why they were not rolling the product out further. He made users free, consumption went way up, and Databricks is now a $200B company. The seat fee blocked more revenue than it collected. A vendor that wants to protect margin can offer a unit price that falls as volume rises. A vendor that adds overage penalties is teaching your agents to stay away, and Lemkin's 90% cut shows how quickly they learn.

There is a risk on the buyer's side too. If you simply demand a lower price with no commitment, a sensible vendor says no, and you are back to throttling. The deal to offer is the one Lemkin's arithmetic describes: unit price at a fifth of today's, in exchange for a commitment to many times today's call volume. On his numbers the vendor ends up with four times the revenue from you and a product sitting inside a workflow that runs all day. Any vendor that turns that down is choosing its renewal model over a quadrupled contract, and you should price its replacement.

The check takes an afternoon. Before your next renewal, list your five biggest software vendors and, for each, the calls per day your agents make and the calls they would make with no price constraint. Multiply the second number by one fifth of today's unit price and put that figure in the first email of the negotiation. If any vendor on the list cannot quote a per-call price at all, start looking for the one that can before the contract auto-renews.

Prompted by If You’re Refounding Your B2B Company for AI, Make Your Product Cheaper. Probably Much Cheaper., SaaStrAI.