Fentner

Markets · Opinion

Recruiters are paying job boards for listings nobody inspects

LinkedIn and Monster removed about 1,500 misleading postings once CBC asked. Anyone buying listings should demand written verified-listing guarantees and credits when postings are pulled.

LinkedIn removed close to 900 postings and Monster 600, and what set it off was a CBC investigation. No screening system did. I expected the usual story about scammers being clever. What surprised me is how little cleverness CBC needed to find them. Its team noticed travel companies with minimal online presence, close to 1,500 postings with near-identical descriptions, roles needing no experience and often no resumé. Then it applied to eight jobs, attaching a blank document where a resumé was required, and was invited to virtual information sessions by people connected to Evolution Travel, the MLM at the centre of the story. A blank document got through, and that is the screening employers pay for when they buy listings.

Consider who is paying whom. Employers and agencies pay LinkedIn and Monster for access to job seekers who believe the listings are real. Job seekers who followed these ones were asked, according to CBC, for hundreds of dollars up front and then a monthly fee. Jay Jones, the Chicago listing investigator CBC consulted, says the platforms earn revenue from this traffic. The article gives no figures and I can't say how much. But CBC reports that the postings reached its journalists through their feeds and through emails from LinkedIn, even though Evolution Travel does not operate in Canada. The platform's own recommendations carried them. I would expect every honest employer posting beside them to pay for that in lower trust from candidates, and nobody invoices for it.

The responsibility chain is murky and I take no view on who sits where in it. Evolution Travel's chief operating officer told CBC the company has consistently told its independent agents not to post job ads on any platform. Archer Travel Services' CEO says it cannot dictate how its 27,000 independent contractors train. Yet a member said in a June 2026 YouTube training video, "We have quite a few different trainings on how to post on LinkedIn." Evolution Travel was among 1,000 companies the FTC put on notice in 2021 over money-making opportunities, and William Kovacic, a former FTC chairman, told CBC the posts would invite enforcement. Regulators can sort that out. A buyer of listings only needs to know whether the inventory is screened.

The best objection is that both platforms already ban misleading postings and MLM listings, both acted on notification, and the posters were third parties breaking the rules. I accept all of that and I don't think LinkedIn wrote these ads. But the buyer's invoice does not say who wrote the listing next to yours. LinkedIn said the companies behind the ads will no longer be able to post, which tells me they could post until a news team applied to eight jobs. Acting only on complaints costs the platform far less than inspecting postings would. The red flags CBC cited were things a database can count: thin company footprints, hundreds of copied job descriptions, no requirements at all. Counting them is cheap next to a newsroom's time.

The wider damage is large. FTC data reported by the Washington Informer put reported losses to online job scams past $220 million by mid-2024, and the FTC cautions that many victims never report, so the real figure is probably higher. That covers all job scams, not Evolution Travel, and I'd want the FTC's own release before leaning on it in a contract dispute. It does show the size of the problem sitting in the inventory you are buying. Platforms profit from listing volume, and every removal subtracts a listing. I would not bet on them tightening up unprompted.

So write it into the contract. Ask your rep for a written verified-listing guarantee: what share of listings in your category come from employers with verified identity, a credit when listings in your category are later pulled for policy breaches, and quarterly removal counts. I could not confirm that either company offers such terms, so find out whether they do. Before your next renewal call, search your own sector's roles and screenshot every posting from a company with almost no web presence and a description copied across dozens of others. Put the screenshots on the table and ask for the discount.

Prompted by LinkedIn, Monster take down over 1,000 fake job postings after CBC investigation | CBC News, CBC.