Markets · Opinion
Your ad budget is rent, and the auction raises it to match your margin
Nobody needs to rig the ad auction. Competitors bid every point of surplus margin into Google's and Meta's revenue, so B2B sellers should move budget to channels they own.
A founder spends $420 in a day, books one call, takes one small order and clears $410. The article that caught my eye calls that a slot machine paying out at 98%, calibrated by the hyperscalers to keep you pulling. I agree with the bill and disagree with the culprit, because I think the slot machine comparison lets Google and Meta off too lightly.
A casino sets its payout, and someone at the casino chose the house edge. In an ad auction nobody at Google or Meta needs to calibrate anything. They sell each impression to the highest bidder, and the bidders do the rest. The article's own account is the sharper one: find an audience that yields an extra 20% margin, and competitors bid the same inventory up until that surplus lands in the platform's quarterly revenue within six months. The platform's incentive is to run the auction well and wait. Every advertiser with a spreadsheet bids up to the point where they break even, so break-even is where the market settles. The 98% figure is the author's image and comes with no source.
That changes what you do about it. If the price of attention converges on your gross margin, then any paid channel that works visibly will have its surplus competed away. The Facebook advertisers who printed 5x returns in 2012 had an empty auction to themselves, and I doubt their copy was better than yours.
So I would treat ad spend as rent and budget it like rent. You pay it to keep a presence, you do not expect it to compound, and you do not call it an investment because the dashboard shows impressions up 14%. A founder who feeds in another five thousand dollars after a ten-dollar loss is paying the landlord, whatever the green percentages on the dashboard say.
The best objection comes from the research the article ignores. The LinkedIn B2B Institute and Ehrenberg-Bass say about 95% of B2B buyers are out of market at any given time. If so, you cannot sit and wait for the 5% to find you, and reach costs money. I accept that. Brand reach is a legitimate expense. My complaint is with paying for the bottom of the funnel at auction prices, bidding on your own name and on the terms of people already shopping, where you pay the platform to introduce you to buyers who were coming anyway. The eBay brand-keyword field experiment by Blake, Nosko and Tadelis is the study I would hand anyone who believes those clicks are all incremental.
The second objection is that owned channels are rented too, and that is true. Google's Helpful Content update in 2023 and 2024 cut organic traffic for publishers who had built whole businesses on search. If your pipeline is a blog, you have swapped one landlord for another. So by owned I mean things a platform cannot switch off with a policy update: an email list people asked to join, customer references a prospect can call, resellers and partners who have signed something, and a sales team that knows the buyer's name. These cost more upfront, produce nothing for a quarter and keep their price when a competitor raises a bid on Google, and finance teams starve them because of the first two.
I would also be careful with the article's last move. It praises the 20-person Indiana packaging plant and sets it against the internet, where it says the other 70% of the economy trades quietly through guilds and referrals. That split comes without a source, and a software company with no installed base cannot copy a plant's trade relationships by deciding to. Relationships are built from customers, and the cheapest early customers are often bought through ads. Use the auction to get the first ones, then stop paying for the second sale.
To see how much of your spend is rent, take your biggest paid campaign, switch it off in one region for a set period, and compare orders there with a matched region where it keeps running. If orders barely move, you have been renting your own customers back from Google, and that budget belongs in references and partner referrals before the next quarterly plan is signed.
Prompted by The 98% Slot Machine, globalcommercegraph.com.