Fentner

Money · Opinion

Stop prepaying AI vendors whose shares trade a few dollars above IPO price

Anthropic's post-IPO slide shows AI vendors are priced on a story. Buyers should refuse multi-year prepaid deals and write exit rights tied to the vendor's finances into every contract.

NBC News reports that Anthropic shares fell 9% on Friday, a day after the IPO, and now sit just a few dollars above the offer price. I have not checked those figures against exchange data, so they are NBC's. If they hold, every procurement lead with an AI renewal on the desk should read them as a message about their own contract, and the message is to stop prepaying.

A multi-year prepaid commitment is a loan. You hand the vendor cash today and receive service over the following years, and the discount you get for doing so is the interest. Buyers almost never price the borrower. For a decade nobody needed to, because the SaaS vendors asking for annual upfront payment were dull and mostly solvent. AI vendors are a different credit. Their costs are compute commitments, and their funding comes from investors who are now being described by Treasury Partners' Richard Saperstein as facing "reduced funding sources for AI-related projects". A borrower in that position, offering you a discount for cash up front, deserves the scrutiny a bank would give.

Consider what the vendor's sales team wants this quarter. A newly listed company trading close to its IPO price needs contracted revenue to show analysts, and a prepaid multi-year deal puts cash on the balance sheet and revenue in the forecast. I expect AI sales teams to push exactly these deals hard over the next few months, with generous discounts attached. I think buyers hold more leverage than they have all year, and most will spend it on a few extra points of discount.

The rest of the news points the same way. NBC says Nvidia fell about 14% after Reuters reported that regulators are scrutinising how the company keeps its books. That is a report of an inquiry, and nobody has shown wrongdoing in anything I have read. But every AI vendor ultimately buys chips from somewhere, and a shock that size at the top of the supply chain reaches customers through capacity and price. Meanwhile Schwab's Kevin Gordon says the Fed is signalling aggressive rate hikes. Higher rates raise the cost of funding for any vendor still spending more than it earns. The S&P 500 is up less than 1% on the year after a seven-day losing streak, and the Nasdaq has given back all of its 2026 gains. For a vendor that still needs outside money, a falling share price and rising rates both make the next funding round more expensive.

I am not predicting Anthropic goes under. Builder.ai's insolvency in 2025 is enough of a reminder that AI vendors do fail, and a customer's prepaid balance is an unsecured claim sitting in a queue behind lenders. Few buyers have asked their lawyers where they would stand.

The best objection comes from the buyer who has already felt capacity constraints. Prepaying, they say, buys a price lock and a guaranteed allocation, and in a rationed market that is worth some credit risk. I accept the allocation point and would pay for it. Commit to a minimum spend, even a large one, and be billed monthly or quarterly as you consume it. Reserved capacity does not require lending the vendor three years of cash. If the vendor insists on prepayment, the discount should beat what Treasuries pay, since NBC says investors are piling into them, plus a premium for the risk.

Where a prepayment is unavoidable, the contract needs three things. First, a termination right at each anniversary. Second, a refund of unused balance within a stated number of days. Third, triggers that let you exit on the vendor's finances: a going-concern warning in its filings, a credit downgrade, a missed payment on its debt, or a formal regulatory investigation into its accounts. Most vendors will push back on the triggers, and their reaction will tell you how much they trust their own forecasts.

Before your next renewal meeting, open the order form you signed this year and find the clause that says what happens to your unused prepaid balance if the vendor stops trading. If there is no such clause, you are already lending to an AI company on terms nobody negotiated.

Prompted by Markets plunge: Nasdaq erases 2026 gains, S&P and Dow enter corrections, NBC News.