Fentner

Companies · Opinion

Goldman kept Anthropic and cut Claude Code to its 12,000 engineers

Goldman Sachs kept Anthropic and limited Claude Code to about 12,000 engineers. Regulated buyers will keep AI vendors as suppliers and shrink the number of people allowed to use them.

I sat down expecting to write that Goldman Sachs had shown AI vendors the door. Pulling Claude Code from bankers and traders looks like a compliance department firing a supplier. The facts don't support that, and I think the correct reading is worse for sellers of AI tools than a lost logo.

Goldman has not dropped Anthropic. Engineers keep Claude Code and GitHub, strats keep access, and Anthropic engineers spent six months inside the bank helping build agents for trade accounting and client onboarding. Goldman and Morgan Stanley are lead underwriters on the S-1 Anthropic filed on 26 October, with the ANT listing expected on Nasdaq before the end of November. The bank is happy to be Anthropic's customer, its banker and its salesman. It just won't let most of its own people near the product.

Do the seat arithmetic. Goldman has roughly 47,000 staff, and more than 12,000 of them are developers. The October guidance limits the coding agents to that group. Whatever a vendor's forecast assumed about a bank-wide rollout, the ceiling is now about a quarter of headcount, and a risk review set it. Accenture funds $29 a month of Claude per employee. Nobody gets to quote a number like that to a firm that has decided most of its people may not log in.

The reasoning behind the review is not mysterious. An agent reads files, writes programs and runs them with the access of whoever is typing. An engineer's code goes through review and testing. A trader's script for watching client flows can end up in daily use with none of that, on a machine that also holds client information, inside a firm that has to keep deal bankers away from traders. I would have made the same call as Goldman's risk people. A compliance officer gets no credit when a trader's clever script works and a very bad year when it doesn't.

That is the vendor's problem, and a better model won't fix it. What failed the review is the way the product is built: it inherits whatever the user can touch. Vendors that win at banks will be the ones selling the controls around the agent, meaning who prompted what, under which entitlements, and which engineer signed off the result. The Hong Kong episode shows how little buyers need to exert this leverage. In April Goldman read its Anthropic contract strictly, according to the Financial Times, and pulled Claude from its Hong Kong bankers. JPMorgan took Claude off its Hong Kong approved list in June. Anthropic's answer was that Claude had never been officially supported there. JPMorgan and Schwab are now blocking outside agents from customer accounts too. A buyer that can cut a product off by reading the paper carefully doesn't need to cancel anything.

The best objection is that Marco Argenti, Goldman's chief information officer, was praising vibe coding by traders and bankers as recently as July, and passing their tools to engineers to be improved. Demand like that, the argument goes, comes back as soon as vendors add controls, so the restriction is a pause. Maybe. But the people who wanted the tool don't hold the budget or the liability, and the people who hold both just spent October saying no. Barclays shows the ceiling from the other side. It expects half its developers on Claude Code by year end and, three weeks after saying so, named developers among 5,000 job cuts. Even the bank that is enthusiastic buys for engineers, then uses the tool to reduce how many engineers it employs. Seats at the one group that qualifies can shrink as well.

So my claim is narrower than the one I started with. Vendors will keep their biggest bank accounts as logos on the customer slide and watch the revenue per account sit well below what a per-employee price list implies. The strangest part is the IPO calendar: Goldman's bankers will spend November selling ANT shares in a company whose coding agent most of them are barred from using.

If you sell agents to a bank, price your next renewal on engineer headcount, which at Goldman is about 12,000, and treat any forecast built on the 47,000 as unsigned until compliance has approved a list of roles.

Prompted by Goldman Sachs Is Pulling Claude Code From Its Bankers and Traders | State of AI, State of AI.